103 Respondents in 10301 St George

20 Respondents in 10310 New & West Brighton

18 Respondents in 10304 Stapleton

15 Respondents in 10314 New Springville

8 Respondents in 10302 Port Richmond

8 Respondents in 10306 New Dorp

7 Respondents in 10303 Mariner’s Harbor

6 Respondents in 10312 Eltingville

5 Respondents in 10305 Rosebank

5 Respondents gave answer N/A

3 Respondents not in Staten Island

2 Respondents in 10308 Great Kills

1 Respondents in 10307 Tottenville

1 Respondents in 10309 Rossville/ Prince’s Bay

# Responses      Age Range

1 Under 18

10 18 - 24

33 25 - 34

34 35 - 44

41 45 - 54

35 55 - 64

45 65+

5       N/A

153 Respondents lived here for more than 20 years

21 Respondents lived here for 1 - 5 years

20 Respondents lived here for 11 - 20 years

8 Respondents lived here for 6 - 10 years

3 Respondents don’t live on Staten Island

Category‍ ‍ ‍‍ Count ‍ ‍ Share

Education‍ ‍ ‍‍ ‍ ‍34 ‍ ‍‍ 18.2%

Retired ‍ ‍‍ ‍‍ 28‍ ‍‍ 15.0%

Healthcare ‍‍ ‍‍ 22 ‍‍ 11.8%

Nonprofit & social services ‍‍ 15 ‍‍ 8.0%

Retail, hospitality & customer service 13 ‍‍ ‍‍ 7.0%

Arts, media & culture ‍‍ 12 ‍‍ 6.4%

Business, management & admin 12 ‍‍ 6.4%

Legal ‍‍ ‍‍ ‍‍ 8 ‍‍ 4.3%

Real estate & property ‍‍ 8 4.3% ‍‍

Construction, trades & operations 7 ‍‍ 3.7%

Technology, engineering & data ‍‍ 6 ‍‍ 3.2%

Unemployed, student or homemaker 6 ‍‍ ‍‍ 3.2%

Government, public service & transit ‍‍5 ‍‍ ‍‍ 2.7%

Business owners & self-employed ‍‍ 4 ‍‍ ‍‍ 2.1%

Advertising & marketing ‍‍ 3 ‍‍ 1.6%

Finance ‍‍ ‍‍ ‍‍ 3 ‍‍ 1.6%

Sports, fitness & recreation ‍‍ 1 ‍‍ 0.5%

Total ‍‍ ‍‍ ‍‍ 187 ‍‍ 100%

46 Respondents are current City employees

8 Respondents are former City employees

11 Respondents are retired City employees

9 Respondents preferred not to say

131 Respondents were not employees of the City

118 Respondents said Yes, regularly

63 Respondents said Occasionally

14 Respondents said Rarely

10 Respondents said I commute or travel another way

Here are the community priorities ranked from most to least frequently selected:

1. Arts, culture, and entertainment — 153 responses, or 74.6%

2. Waterfront access, such as promenades and piers — 131 responses, or 63.9%

3. Grocery stores — 121 responses, or 59.0%

4. Public recreational space — 119 responses, or 58.0%

5. Green/open space and environmental concerns — 115 responses, or 56.1%

6. NYC Parks and Recreation — 75 responses, or 36.6%

7. Parking — 67 responses, or 32.7%

8. Commercial space — 66 responses, or 32.2%

9. Youth programs and education — 62 responses, or 30.2%

10. Transportation and commuting — 57 responses, or 27.8%

11. Accessibility for people with disabilities — 46 responses, or 22.4%

12. Public safety — 40 responses, or 19.5%

13. Residential opportunities — 37 responses, or 18.0%

14. Healthcare and wellness options — 35 responses, or 17.1%

The clearest priorities were arts and entertainment, waterfront access, grocery stores, recreation, and green/open space. Residential opportunities ranked near the bottom.

“Urgent Health Care facility needed” - Respondent #4

“We are a food desert. Having healthier grocery options would be great.” - Respondent #5

“The area really needs an affordable but high quality grocery store as well as new housing stock” - Respondent #6

“Affordable groceries and childcare to make it easy for people who commute to Manhattan for work.” - Respondent #9

“A major grocery store” - Respondent #11

“Free parking options to address the congestion in surrounding residential neighborhood. The staten Island mall offers such why not here.” - Respondent #12

“It is a shame for a prime waterfront site to not include maritime uses. Commercial space should serve the community, not tourists. I'd like to see small retail that serves those who live nearby and pass through to the ferry like flower shop, shoe repair, hardware store, good groceries like Whole Foods or Trader Joe's. I really miss Nordstrom Rack because I could buy shoes in my neighborhood instead of going to a mall. The large spaces of EO could be used for light manufacturing and provide jobs with the amazing transportation of the ferry right next door for workers.” - Respondent #13

“SI needs an economy of its own, with on-island professional jobs outside of the healthcare sector. Develop discount 'incubator' office space for creative industries and nonprofits with a mission beyond local social services. Inviting such jobs in SI in turn makes Staten Island a viable housing market for those who'd otherwise be living in Brooklyn. In turn, the consumption patterns of professionals living here brings fresh opportunity for the expansions of the retail and services which, once in place, might attract more professional employers.” - Respondent #14

“HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES. There are many communities down south that are a vibrant mixture of retail shops and housing above with dedicated parking buildings included at no cost.” - Respondent #16

“Having a supermarket or something like Trader Joes. There is so much dead space in the outlets that could be used and having it located next to a major transit hub makes it easier for people using public transit to access.” - Respondent #18

“Lack of good grocery shopping” - Respondent #19

“How to deal with the [large] ugly parking lot” - Respondent #22

“Lack of quality and affordable grocery stores” - Respondent #23

“local arts and crafts stores that accommodate some classes for children” - Respondent #26

“Yes, a lack of adequate, public outdoor green space and housing.” - Respondent #27

“We desperately need grocery stores in this neighborhood, plus more restaurants.” - Respondent #28

“Commercial:  Supermarkets,  Banks, restaurants, parking,  retail shopping” - Respondent #30

“Richmond Terrance area is a food desert. I think it would be great having another grocery store such as Trader’s Joe or Whole Foods. Many commuters stop and do their shopping before getting on the island. I believe the only grocery store near the ferry is Keyfood and then after that is Western Beef.” - Respondent #31

“Need for cultural and artistic space that combined with commercial and residential space would attract more people to the area and make it safer and more enjoyable.” - Respondent #32

“350,000 sq ft over close to 4 acres in NYC real estate. That's more than enough space to mix permeable green space with recreational opportunities, Smorgasbord style comercial space for local entrepreneurs, gallery space and a community run grocery store. We don't need another Nike or Nordstrom outlet and never did. We need reasonably priced access to fresh produce and space that by and for the community” - Respondent #33

“Grocery Store or even a Trader Joes, A drug store with Pharmacy, Large retail to bring more local amenities like restaurants, ( like there used to be. The orginal stores for EO - so many have left. The sushi place and clinton hall were nice to have.

These little handmade market shops are so uninviting. A TJMaxx would be great.” - Respondent #34

“Put Staten on the map and make it less than a caricature by involving local businesses” - Respondent #39

“There are very few ADA accessible event spaces or meeting places on the island.” - Respondent #45

“Its a food desert” - Respondent #46

“Gathering spaces, cafes, wellness programs for seniors, restaurants.” - Respondent #47

"the North shore is a vacuum ! this space was created to bring folks here from the Ferry to encourage them to want to see more of the Island. Instead they come shop and return to whereever they originated.  They are not even friendly.  we need a viable Gym there, a nice Restauranr/Coffee shop for folks to rest enjoying regular Cuisine no specialties.  The Island is full of "special eateries".  We could use a "general" type store that would accomodate home, clothing, specialties.  Yes something for the youth to interest them more than hanging out. I have more ideas but this should be enough to begin. Thank you’ - Respondent #48

“More spaces for youth, cleaning up the streets and trash, more activities on the weekends for youth to participate in.” - Respondent #49

“We used to have open water view from the SI Ferry to Westervelt ave.  Walking was lovely.  Now, ugly.  The mall could have been  2 or 3 stories (instead of 5) with a green roof.  It would be full and lovely.” - Respondent #61

“St George needs a bank.” - Respondent #63

“I believe Staten Island, the north shore, and St George need a large gathering space for everyone but especially young adult (20-35). Something similar to Chelsea Piers, Pier 17, or Dumbo. A mix of commerical, residential, and artistic space would bring a sense of community and pride to the area in addition potential tourist revenue. The idea should celebrate what makes St George and Staten Island unique (Sri Lanka food, Wu-Tang, and Italian). Staten Islanders should see themselves in the space.” - Respondent #64

“The area currently lacks a supermarket, a drug store, a movie theater, hardware store. In addition to the retail shops that I frequent, I would like the development to include these "main street" types of shops and services, making available one-stop access to necessities, luxuries, and entertainment.” - Respondent #65

“There are very few walkable grocery store options in st. george” - Respondent #68

“We need more urgent care centers, banks, grocery stores, maybe a movie theatre, adult day care centers and a playground for kids, performing arts center, space for artists to create and produce. The Outlets have ample space to have everything that we need and then some” - Respondent #70

“We need doctors and groceries and a pharmacy” - Respondent #72

“Cradle to grave uses of the space by all ages. Activities that link with vocationally trained and university trained careers in climate-change energy solutions, maritime trades, climate change land use resilience and technological development-- so that Staten Islanders can work locally at jobs that pay home-ownership incomes.” - Respondent #81

“More parks dept type facilities.  Affordable co-working or coffee shops, bookstore, moderate hotel and restaurant” - Respondent #83

“Lack of viable supermarkets, parking, easy access, commercial stores with reasonable rents” - Respondent #85

“I think a food store like Whole Foods or Trader Joe’s is needed in the St George area. Brunch places!” - Respondent #87

“Add value to help balance the social status the north shore / outlet area is viewed as not opportunistic to visit and almost shunned as crime ridden. This area is grossly underutilized and only adds to make the prior statement correct.” - Respondent #88

“St. George promenade needs visibility to harbor, cut trees, new water fountains, benches, tables and repaving” - Respondent #90

“Sports fields…specifically soccer” - Respondent #92

“An anchor grocery store like a Trader Joes would attract SI residents & provide a much-needed service in a food desert.” - Respondent #94

“Lack of youth activities. Lack of youth jobs.” - Respondent #95

“Food in all its  aspects, food trucks, farmers markets, grocery stores” - Respondent #96

“There needs to be affordable home ownership options.’ - Respondent #97

“We need a grocery store we need health care offices within walking distance we need stores like TJ Maxx Marshalls also a pet store for our pets to eat. Also affordable commercial space for small businesses.” - Respondent #99

“i think there's not enough to do in that area it's boring. Nothing attracts people to it and there's too many troubled people walking around it.” - Respondent #101

“Improved grocery stores, the men's shelter on Stuyvesant generates unpleasantness, too much evidence of drug use all over the sidewalks” - Respondent #103

“A grocery store. New brighton is a nutritional food desert” - Respondent #104

“There are few free public spaces for people and kids to spend time. We need more of these 'third' spaces. Its an important part of building healthy communities.” - Respondent #107

“Anything that can improve the lives of Staten Islanders while maintaining this space as a commuter hub. I think recreational space, arts and entertainment, youth space are all great ideas to keep the space open to the public, available for parking still and something for ALL residents.” - Respondent #110

“More space with free access to the outdoors. Opportunities for a grocery store like Trader Joe’s for people to shop before and after work.” - Respondent #111

“This site is a crucial transportation link for surrounding neighborhoods.  We desperately need Bus Rapid Transit to encourage bus use and speed commutes from Mariners Harbor, through New Brighton and to St. George. A BRT route through the wheel and outlets to the ferry terminal would alleviate traffic on Richmond Terrace and improve the safety and walkability of the surrounding streets. We also urgently need pedestrian and bike access through the wheel site to connect with Bank Street, which is today desolate, unsecure and underutilized because the only ingress/egress is at Jersey Street.” - Respondent #114

“The space could be used to provide more access to the waterfront, provide more housing opportunities (the Island is in desperate need of affordable apartments and senior housing), and integrate into a wider cultural and recreational corridor centered on the ferry. This idea, the MERC (Maritime Education Recreation Corridor), was proposed several years ago and provides a solid roadmap for balancing different needs in the community.” - Respondent #119

“Recreational space is needed for sports and things for young adults and older adults to do.” - Respondent #120

“I think it would be great to have some sort of community space for the public to be able to access. There needs to be ways that the residents in the area can feel connected with their community and some sort of public theatre or arts space for rent and booking.” - Respondent #123

“Apart from local restaurants, there is nothing to do in St George. A community space for teens to go after-school or a movie theater would be welcome.” - Respondent #124

“Space for the youth, gym, GROCERIES, pharmacy” - Respondent #125

“Multi purpose space. Especially free or low cost options.” - Respondent #127

“Lack of maritime education for good jobs” - Respondent #129

“Super markets, Trader Joe's heath foods, a large center with doctors offices for all manner of health and dental issues. A couple of really  good high end  dry cleaners, close to the terminal that you could drop off and pick up your clothes, and get to the ferry, busses or subway quickly.” - Respondent #132

“there are no public soccer fields on this side of the island” - Respondent #133

“There is no decent place to go grocery shopping” - Respondent #134

“Yes a train from St. George to mariners harbor as they were supposed to years ago. Connect the north shore  to the south shore via train . Also shopping and bars and restaurants so I don’t have to go to the city to have a good time on a Friday night” - Respondent #135

“I liked the idea of the " mall" & shops but it should have been an indoor space. Hard to shop when it's so cold.” - Respondent #141

“Staten Island desperately needs venues and community spaces that provide more to the public than just a place to shop or eat. We need a place that fosters community, the arts, hosts shows and performances and gives back to the community.” - Respondent #142

“More good food spots late night” - Respondent #144

“Nothing is going to do well in this area until the crime is cleaned up. I personally know dozens of people who say they will never go down there because it’s not safe. They would rather spend the money and go to New Jersey.” - Respondent #145

“It could use an easy to access grocery store from the ferry. Plus the community could use more green space.” - Respondent #151

“Food desert! Can use more grocery shopping options.” - Respondent #153

“I would love to see this space used as a boardwalk area with restaurants and shops.” - Respondent #154

“Food desert” - Respondent #155

“programs for the youth to give them on the right path and transportation to make commuting to and from Staten Island easier.” - Respondent #158

“Wheel Site: Waterfront access, similar to redeveloped Brooklyn waterfront. Creation of a MERC (Maritime Education and Recreation Corridor) opening up waterfront access specifically to benefit students off all ages from around NYC, which could bring in partnerships with organizations like the Billion Oyster Project, Hudson River Foundation and other stewards of NY Harbor. Empire Outlets: using empty space to house businesses that would bring in locals from all of Staten Island as well as residents from lower Manhattan, such as a dine in movie theater such as Alamo Drafthouse, midsized grocery store similar to Trader Joe’s, Met Foods, Lidl or Aldi  Classroom space for educational field experiences for students, art space for showcasing local work and/or temporary exhibits similar to the SI Arts space that used to be inside the ferry terminal. Supporting local businesses to encourage Staten Island businesses to open in EO, similar to the previous Pop Up and Grow program that brought in locally owned stores such as Vanity House Designs, BB Bombs, Badass Boot Camp, etc.” - Respondent #160

“We have limited safe communal recreation space on North Shore. New rec center at Lyons does not include a public year round pool. We desperately need one for school swim teams, youth swim lessons and aquatic recreation and rehabilitation opportunities. This could also help alleviate our problems training and retaining lifeguards for our multiple public pools and beaches, especially if swim lessons are able to be provided year round. I enjoyed shopping at Empire outlets and saw many tourists there. It is a beautiful retail space and should be revamped and redesigned to have more shopping and dining with opportunities to enjoy the waterfront area via walking , biking paths. The area by Dumbo was trash until renovated, and merry-go-round became a huge draw. No one I know from mid to south SI will ever consider coming to St. George to dine, drink, shop or see a baseball game.” - Respondent #164

“More 3rd spaces or activities” - Respondent #165

“We need more access to our waterfront. We also need sports fields on the north shore. Soccer fields, and basketball courts. Our sports teams have to travel to the south shore for every soccer game.

We also need more food shopping that’s better than keyfood. Maybe a fairway or Whole Foods.” - Respondent #169

“St. George is a grocery store desert. Opening a grocery store at the Empire Outlets would be a huge benefit for all in the neighborhood.” - Respondent #170

“There’s a distinct lack of diversity of cultural activities.” - Respondent #172

“This is a food desert. We need a Trader Joes or market. What I believe would be successful is a movie theater and bowling alley to keep people on-site to attract restaurants and retail.” - Respondent #175

“As a business owner, we could make leaving the terminal and exploring the neighborhood more enticing.  Info Kiosk with local businesses listed would be nice.” - Respondent #176

“Public parkland, public access, no more commercial development except putting a good grocery store in existing space.” - Respondent #180

“ Low cost store like Target or Walmart for local residents” - Respondent #182

“I think that discounted parking should be made available to the many public employees who work in the area to alleviate overcrowded streets and lack of parking for those of us who live in the area.” - Respondent #183

“We absolutely need space for children! Families! Teens! We can make money on this people will come for a special family friendly place. It can serve as park, mall, community center. The ball field next door is a draw for this too!” - Respondent #184

“I live in a food desert. I would like to see a supermarket come to life in st. George, tomskinville, new Brighton or Randalls manor with affordable prices especially on greens and fruits. The problem with proposed grocery stores it that's is more expensive and offer limited options.” - Respondent #186

“I think having more business activity and access at waterfront will bring attention needed. Highline. Restaurant on a boat etc. it will have to be multiple at once rather than one at a time that tend to sadly fail” - Respondent #187

“Safety”. - Respondent #193

“hair/nail salons, wine/liquor store, hardware store, drug store chain (tho I don't want to see the St. George Pharmacy on Stuyvesant Pl go out of business), bank branch.” - Respondent #195

“We need more park and recreational spaces on the North Shore. We have one tiny park within walking distance for the local children, Lt Lia.” - Respondent #197

“safety/crime” - Respondent #198

“More retail, - more grocery stores” - Respondent #200

“We need a place with shops and clubs for locals and residents” - Respondent #201

“Need more spaces for local events, art installations, music, and movies.” - Respondent #203

“Please support local art and artists -- whether by creating subsidized spaces for artists to work and live or a venue to display their work. People come for art and culture, no malls.” - Respondent #204

“This space could be used as a hub for cultural events, community board meetings and other civic options in addition to some retail space” - Respondent #206

“If there were a grocery store and cafes and pubs, A bookstore, healthcare offices for primary care and pediatric care; barber shop and hair salon, a gym; a playground; dog park.” - Respondent #9

“The outlets should be space for our community to gather and for our needs to be met. There should be a major grocery store, a bank, community organizations, independent stores, programming, and space for us to relax and enjoy the views and waterfront.” - Respondent #11

“St. George needs business which serve the local community, not just tourists. One major gap is in goods and services needed by commuters who should be able to stop and shop/run errands: high-quality general grocer and specialty shops for staples of SI's ethnic groups; an urgent care facility; a day care center; outdoor seasonal food/holiday markets; perhaps a small movie theater.

Keep the lights on, and keep it clean. Add places to sit safe from inclement weather. Stop the 120th Precinct cops from parking on the waterfront roadway. Have seasonal markets. Have space usable for community meetings/events at low or no cost - I'd shop incidental to going to/coming from them. I'd LOVE to spend more time at EO in inclement weather, but the lack of any rain-protecting overhand leaves even the covered walkways wet in rainy or snowy weather (why on earth would a covered walkway be left so vulnerable to rainfall?).” - Respondent #14

“ADA-accessible art & music venue! I’m disabled and when I want to see bands I have to go off the island because aside from flagship, none of the existing bars are able to accommodate my friends who are in wheelchairs.” - Respondent #45

“We could use a good bakery, a CVS/Duane Reade (since the old one closed), a morning coffee spot (since the one in the terminal closed), and food stalls along the water to encourage tourists to stick around and enjoy the view” - Respondent #25

“Maybe a jazz club and a restaurant, water sports; arts and crafts places for kids; maybe some theatre opportunities, beach” - Respondent #26

“The North Shore Action Plan includes waterfront paths but the St. George section is very narrow in some areas. A wider area adjoining it would provide more outdoor space for the community- more like the Hudson River Park. The forested area that was omitted at the EDC visioning must be included.” - Respondent #27

“Antique mall.  Flea market.  Food hall.  Grocery stores.  Movie theater.  A small selection of retail shops.  Parkland where the wheel was.” - Respondent #28

“Park w/ tennis/pickleball courts, basketball courts, playground, picnic area (similar to Rockefeller Park in Manhattan), Trader Joe’s, free kayaking” - Respondent #29

“Waterfront park space like battery park and above” - Respondent #30

“I think having Apple at the space might also attract more tourists and people. People usually stay in Apple for a long period of time and can be useful with events and trips for schools. I think the space needs more stores and food options. It sucked when Nordstrom rack and American Eagle closed down since I always shopped there. The space is great to hang out and has a beautiful view but need more events, more stores and options to really be able to enjoy it.” - Respondent #31

“I am speaking to EO here. I live here so need a good grocery - not another Key Food. restaurants. There is already a theatre.  Maybe a TJ Maxx - wish Nordstroms Rack was still there.

Regarding the Wheel space - it should emulate Hudson River Park by Vesey street - Playgrounds, biking, walking.a little cafe.” - Respondent #34

“Music concerts, restaurants, senior exercise classes, grocery and farmer markets” - Respondent #36

“Grocery stores and transit signage in conjunction with the upcoming esplanade!” - Respondent #39

“Grocery store, music venue, outdoor and activities kid friendly” - Respondent #41

“Community hub/community center. A multipurpose space that reflects the needs of the community in one place. Programming and space for youth, not just music venues but also practice spaces.” - Respondent #42

“Safe comfortable public space to walk, enjoy a coffee or drink as well as the view. Smaller and better. The outlet is too big and empty and unwelcoming now.” - Respondent #43

“More restaurants shopping bars a tourist attraction and place commuters can enjoy traveling to nyc daily” - Respondent #44

“I would like to see more cultural and creative businesses such as wellness and art centers, unique restaurants and cafes, not the typical chain foods, more sports and fitness programs, maybe a dance studio, home made bakeries, shoreline activities like kayaking, picnic facilities, boutiques but not big chain clothes stores, a community of attractive, original enterprises for us and tourists.” - Respondent #47

“coffee shops, study areas, clean sitting areas, more indoor activities- bowling or arcades, farmers market,” - Respondent #49

“Indoor events for adults and children.” - Respondent #50

“Free and community based events” - Respondent #52

“A Health Care Center to address basic health needs .” - Respondent #54

“Kayaking, art & culture, make use of the existing good court and make it more accessible to the public and affordable for vendors. Hold the DOT accountable for the abysmal and uninviting conditions in the ferry terminal.

Offer free or low cost tours and assistance to tourists coming from the ferry to increase visitation to businesses in the outlets and St George. Offer free shuttles for tourists to cultural institutions throughout Staten Island.” - Respondent #55

“I enjoyed having the exercising equipment with the walking path overlooking the water.” - Respondent #57

“I would like to see a farmers market, retail space and fine dining with water views and maybe a fishing pier too.” - Respondent #58

“Public parks, spaces to work out, lots of green areas with public programming and hosts farmers markets.” - Respondent #60

“We had (in the past) a spectacular waterfront.  I would like to see a walkway like the Hudson River Greenway, from Fort Wadsworth to Snug Harbor.  How about becoming part of Gateway National Park.  Or, The MERC. Learn about the MERC  --https://youtu.be/QYzVOofueL0?si=k3y3eFqaspp0ZNJp” - Respondent #60

“Movie Theater, Whole Foods, Retail stores, bowling alley, restaurants” - Respondent #63

“Food court. Something like a bowling alley, driving range or rock climbing; a high up green space roof with a nice view of the harbor, concert space (think little island amphitheater), grocery store, movie theater” - Respondent #64

“A large grocery that has broader food options, especially fresh produce.” - Respondent #68

“I notated this in the previous question but once the basic needs of the community have been addressed, then maybe we can think of using the space for recreation and other activities.” - Respondent #70

“Specialized medicine. People would travel from other boroughs and they would shop in grocery and book stores while in the area and waiting for their appointments.” - Respondent #72

“As long as it’s sustainable/environmentally conscious and designed/policed in a way to maintain safety. I’ve seen men congregating drinking publicly near EO & the NYC Ferry, which is very disturbing. I’d hate to see more urban blight.” - Respondent #77

“A university/vocational school for climate change solutions and tecnologies using our New York harbor for sustainable maritime industries of the future. Such an institution attached to a technology incubator would bring young people as students and monetize the space with high paying professor and administrator jobs. Campuses of adult learning offer greater capacity for open public outdoor spaces, with vibrant youth culture that opens demographic groups that eat at restaurants and seek locally created art and culture experiences. Add a NYPL Music Library with windowscape views of the harbor to listen on headphones to worlds music collection, music performance space, and conference space to curate and celebrate our local music industry that created Hip Hop and continues to be developed with immigration of African and Asian populations.

We are a global society in a waterfront community-- we should offer outlets for every Staten Islander to grow skills and experience our waterfront for career, health, culture, and recreation.” - Respondent #81

“Retail, food quick serve and sit down, game and recreation-

Place for older teens young adults to play games like D&D

Place for individuals with ASD to meet, hang out, meet others

High functioning individuals with ASD or other nuero divergent people need welcoming places to meet

Other like minded people” - Respondent #82

“A city gym, a better library, affordable bars and restaurants, an indoor food court with wifi, piers like those at Chelsea piers with trees and grass. Lawn space. An indoor mall. A Gansevoort Peninsula type beach ⛱️” - Respondent #83

“I think this could be an opportunity for many things for entertainment. Make it a fun zone, one area for zip lining, rock climbing, and other physical entertainment, another for area for cheaper movies, an area for art galleries, a video arcade area, a escape room, a place to make art, there could be a place also that has staff that gives out pamphlets all the other things to do on the island, there could be a area that’s a teen hangout, as well as a area for elderly to play chess/knit/etc. this should be something that helps the people of Staten Island have things to do, but also gives a opportunity for tourists to enjoy and maybe spend some money and learn about the rest of the island, because we all know they take the ferry and then go right back to the Manhattan side. Oh and there could be street fair and free events that happen in the space on weekends.” - Respondent #84

“Our community needs an easily accessible commercial space with reasonable rents to encourage businesses to come.  Rather than tax benefits and grants for the developers, give it to the businesses to encourage them to join the community.  There is not large supermarket within easy access to Northeast SI.  We need restaurants, banks, hardware, big  stores, small shops, adequate parking and improved access via roads. The developers and private equity groups have; made their millions while ruining the area; now let the residents benefit from a viable, thriving plan.  There is no reason the outlets are empty.  No one is being helpful to fill them.” - Respondent #85

“Food store and restaurants. Play ground for young children, to encourage families. Artist space to work and sell. Brewery like: Staten Island Women’s Home Brew. Think Industry City or any other successful waterfront or indoor market in NYC.” - Respondent #87

“A marina would bring some vitalization. There was a marina way back when. Nice grocery stores that people won’t mind traveling to with ample free parking. Even a target!  Again without addressing the local needs people won’t feel safe coming to these stores. Knock that awful looking structure down around the wheel it looks like a real estate graveyard. Anything would be an improvement.” - Respondent #88

“Community garden, good grocery store, community classes (Zumba, yoga, art,), community meeting space, creative playground for different aged kids. Take Battery Park City’s new Wagner Park as a model” Respondent #89

“Waterfront park like Brooklyn Bridge Park including sports fields, basketball courts, sprinkler park and restaurants” - Respondent #92

“Arts & cultural center, NYC inspired.

Interactive, industrial, a space that can be used for various events” - Respondent #93

“Anchor grocery store, continued shopping oulet, additional outdoor recreation, venue for outdoor arts & cultural events, food vendors” - Respondent #94

“Youth activity space, especially for teens” - Respondent #95

“It needs to be cleaner, better lit, and more security, private or NYPD or both” - Respondent #96

“Mid-rise buildings with home ownership option. Arts and entertainment options, restaurants, localy owned stores and waterfront access.” - Respondent #97

“Think like domino park. Why can’t we have that type of energy here.  The commercial spaces in the empire outlets are not fit for the many people in the community to open a business. Grocery stores and healthcare clinics, a pet store for the animals.” - Respondent #99

“Top golf, mom and pop shoes like a village town are good attraction for tourists.” - Respondent #100

“Gallery space. We don't have enough of it. There was a store there that sold local artist stuff. I wish that would come back. More restaurants.” - Respondent #101

“Safer bike through passages connecting to other neighborhoods, better grocery stores, total rehab of the esplanade” - Respondent #103

“A movie screening space, interactive playground with sprinkler. Sensory garden” - Respondent #104

“The north shore needs a movie theatre and a Trader Joe’s. Good, waterfront dining and performance venues!” - Respondent #105

“The area needs more activities for the public. Maybe Something like Bryant park . An open space with a few nice restaurants and some shops. Or Maybe a driving range , miniature golf, roller skating rink , and a decent grocery store . Something to that both the residents and tourists would enjoy.” - Respondent #106

“Whatever is there needs to be easily accessible. The area is crowded, expensive, difficult to park and overall claustrophobic.  Park, big nice bathrooms, bike paths, sitting areas, picnic areas, small skatepark, small place for live outdoor music that is FREE TO ATTEND. Also accessible to people with disabilities. Let there be a place for access a ride to go right inside, ramps, braille/easily walked paths for poor eyesight etc.” - Respondent #107

“Events and mixed use- a place to hang out with family” - Respondent #108

“A place for fun! A roller rink, a retro arcade, brewery, shops!” - Respondent #109

“Kids activities space, a museum, entertainment options, green space, urban farm - anything that can be used by many people equally and make it a space for everyone.” - Respondent #110

“Parks department activities, grass, walking paths, benches, park stands for food / drink, outdoor exercise, outdoor concerts, outdoor art exhibits, farmers markets, nearby grocery stores.” - Respondent #111

“I think that there should be a boutique hotel in the second building of empire outlets as originally planned I believe. A grocery store such as Trader Joe’s. More food/bar options. And section of the outlets dedicated to the arts and entertainment.

As far as the wheel garage either tear or down and make it green space and recreation like the waterfront on the east and west side of Manhattan.  If that is not feasible possibly pickleball courts or something that can be used all seasons.” - Respondent #112

“Convention Center/ Expo Space, Art Gallery, Restaurants and food court.” - Respondent #113

“I would like to see more attractions and activities serving locals (not just tourists). A book store with author events or clubs, a gaming arcade, a skatepark, a climbing gym, a kitchen supply store with cooking workshops.  I would like to see arts facilities like dance studios, glassblowing, ceramics, etc.” - Respondent #114

“Nice place to go sit view Manhattan. Places to grab a bite to eat and maybe a supermarket.” - Respondent #117

“I would like to see a pier of some sorts, one where people can go and hang out, have games on there and enjoy food. Something fun” - Respondent #118

“Seating, dedicated viewing areas, cultural programming” - Respondent #119

“Outdoor waterfront activities, concerts, restaurants with live entertainment, lounges, sports/recreation centers. Things to do so we don't have to leave the island. Rock climbing, arcade, mini golf, unique spas, lots and lots of good food.

Even a trade school would be good there. It could be like a college town with family things to do in the day and upscale bar scene at night.” - Respondent #120

“We are in a food desert for affordable organic food. We need open green space with great playground and the road reopened along the water. Kayaking, art gallery for local artists, cultural center for high quality ongoing events- outdoor like Little Island—and indoor like the Shed. Bring your people together but NOT to go shopping.” - Respondent #121

“Kid friendly, maybe laser tag, bowling, trampoline, and then great food options. A place where families can go for a night out.” - Respondent #122

“I think affordable housing and access to affordable groceries are paramount given the lack of these vital amenities in the neighborhood. Theirs is also a crucial need for community space in which St. George residents can connect with each other. Lastly waterfront access is critical.” - Respondent #123

“ 1. For this space we need to start with affordable healthy food options for the North shore. Not having to "schlep" with bags from the city as many North shore residents can't make it to the only ones out on the island.  And commuters can also help and I am sure because there is parking, people will come to shop.

2. A movie theater, an Alamo or just anything else would do. We have to drive far or go to the city.

3. A bookstore.

4. Space for yoga and workout (affordable)

5. Space to hang, make it green, benches etc. The space at the water is great, always too busy, the rest is too concrete. Make it lush, have community garden.

6. Some places to shop, miss the Walgreen, miss the Northstrom, i would go and buy all present and suitcases and really supported them

7. community meeting place/co-working spaces.

8. An urgent care” - Respondent #125

“Perfect wedding venue, residential options for foot traffic” - Respondent #126

“Recreation center for youth, there are several schools including two high schools. Grocery stores, chain stores, small business stores waterfront space where people can go and enjoy scenic views low cost as well as being able to support local businesses with food/drink/activity options.  Like Central park or a mini Coney Island by the water. Affordable housing and parking.” - “Respondent #127

“I would love the space to feel more green and have more access to recreational activity.” - Respondent #128

“Urban farm, MERC, and film industry” - Respondent #129

“Park / playground / waterfront dining” - Respondent #130

“More Outdoor eating, bar, supermarket, target, outdoor movies, food trucks, fireworks, basketball court, gym, arcade, flag football field, office space before residential housing, thrift store, top golf, peloton, blow out bar, nail salon, hotel” - Respondent #131

“Scenic views of Jersey, Manhatten and Brooklyn that I could photograph from day and at night, open to the public at all times. A haven that wild life would be attracted to. A nice place to walk through with lovely flowers and plants and trees.” Respondent #132

“Contemporary art space, Walking space, green space, playgrounds, music like an the Hudson River Park” - Respondent #137

“Put a venue there for musicians. Only active venue left on Staten is mother pugs! Would drive new life into the area” - Respondent #140

“Outdoor park like spaces all long Richmond Terrace to Ferry. Like the Highline in Manhattan,  but with bike path, play areas for children & places to picnic. Even have outdoor art installations.  Allow food trucks on weekends.  Maybe even build a pool .” - Respondent #141

“I’d love to see a community center, venue space, or an arts and cultural center” - Respondent #142

“Bowling Alley, Arcade, VR arena, laser tag, carnival games, etc. make an entire entertainment and restaurant district that can be used 24/7. Finish and reopen the wheel garage, open up the space for additional parking and green space. Organize block parties and events with the ferryhawks on the site” - Respondent #143

“They should’ve never closed Stapleton Studios if they left well enough alone, that place would’ve brought in an immense amount of revenue, which would’ve beefed up the entire area.” - Respondent #145

“The biggest issue is safety. I would love a park if you are willing to invest in public safety. The other nearby parks are full of sketchy people. Brooklyn Bridge Park looks really nice because it has a lot of shade, kayaking, pickleball, dog park, and bright lights. Free parking is important for local residents. Stores like restaurant and grocery is good too. It's not a kid friendly area due to lack of good schools.” - Respondent #152

“Boardwalk, restaurant, shops, gardens, environmental and youth amenities.” - Respondent #154

“For the young, concerts. for the old ,f airs and markets like vegetables and crafts” - Respondent #157

“more sport eventings/concerts with famous artists would draw more attention and traffic to SI. I find the main reason people come to SI is just to ride the ferry to see the Statue of Liberty and turn back to Manhattan. We need reasons to draw people to SI and make them stay for awhile.” - Respondent #158

“It needs good food option. Build a time-out food hall there. Something that people will travel to” - Respondent #161

“The parking the garage should be razed to the ground and the area turned into a green field again. (Leave the four giant feet of the ferris wheel for adventurous kids to play on).” - Respondent #162

“There needs to be more open recreational opportunities along the waterfront to walk, bike and enjoy the views. We need a year round public pool in SI, this would enable youth swim lessons,  school swim teams and aquatic recreation and rehabilitation opportunities that are lacking compared to other boroughs. This will also help our lifeguard shortage if we begin teaching and encouraging young swimmers. I loved shopping at Empire outlets. No one I know mid or south SI will ever come to dine, drink, shop  or see a ball game in St. George because they view it as unsafe and parking unaccessible. They wont take the direct SI train due to safety concerns. Revamp the are with shopping, dining and recreation space like DUMBO so tourists and licals will come and enjoy. Clean and safe are priorities” - Respondent #164

“Indoor basketball court, indoor skating, arcade, bars, wellness center, amusement park, go karts, lounge’ - Respondent #165

“Most importantly to serve the communities is a new combined intermediate school and high school with an indoor pool, could be a harbor school. Curtis has been overcrowded for years as well as IS 61. This would be for for the students and the North Shore.” - Respondent #166

"Movie theaters, event spaces, cultural and recreational spaces.  As of now it’s just becoming a run down and empty.” - Respondent #167

“I want more recreational areas for children and adults. And it needs to be open for all schools to use not just public school children.

I want to see more parks and access to the waterfront.  STOP building more housing. We don’t need more people in our island. It’s over crowded.

Another great idea for this space is a market. Hudson yards has the Spanish market with stores and restaurants. In Brooklyn they have a Japanese market. Let’s do something like this with possibly different cultures of the area represented. Sri Lanken, polish, Albanian etc. it would be fun to try different foods and be able to shop there too. Or better yet also add a butcher, fish monger, bakery etc.” - Respondent #169

“I live on the waterfront and it’s disappointing that there’s no areas to really walk around and enjoy. We are currently limited to the promenade adjacent to the Outlets, opposite the Ballpark, where the Postcards memorial is. We are the only waterfront community in NYC that hasn’t been properly invested in. So much wasted potential.” - Respondent #170

“Museums, cultural experiences, maybe something like the piers on the west side” - Respondent #171

“Outdoor Concerts would be cool. Something well connected to the rest of the borough. More than just the usual shopping and other boring things.” - Respondent #172

“A walk way along the waterfront with shops and restaurants” - Respondent #173

“A rock climbing wall/center (there are none for adults on Staten Island.) Perhaps a dance studio for all ages. A small arthouse performance space would be nice. Small indie films movie theater (we have the blockbuster theaters already.” - Respondent #175

“With the closing of South Beach amusement park there came as sad void of reasonably priced things for families to do. We don’t need the largest ferris wheel in the world.. But a reasonably sized wheel would be lovely and maybe a small family friendly amusement park. There aren’t many places like that anymore and Baby it could be something that was managed by the New York City parks department. Something like the carousel at Willowbrook. Maybe a small arcade. There are things that we can do to bring back an old world charm that Staten Island used to have.  St George is constantly doing these soulless projects.  Something magical and capable of creating happy memories for children would be really nice.” - Respondent #176

“More stores on this side...shopping centers to make it more appealing and not have to travel across the island.  Stores like trader Joe's. Pharmacies. Brand name stores if outlets remain.” - Respondent #177

“We need public waterfront access and use, not private or for-profit development or use.” - Respondent #180

“Movie Theatre” - Respondent #181

“Target and sports community space....rink, basketball, golf range and soccer field” - Respondent #182

“I think a grocery store would be a great addition. Additionally, I think the space should be used for doctors’ offices to provide convenient healthcare options to residents without having to travel to other areas of the Island.” Respondent #183

“Arcades, food, art space, ect! I’m a busy mom who’s husband commutes and we are at the empire outlets all the time. I can’t park anywhere if I wanted to do a little shopping before I grab him. If we could get tourists with Staten Island staples at the Empire Outelts. Then make family centered food and fun people will come for water views while their kids can play!” - Respondent 184

“Residential and commercial would be great so the folks who live there can go food shopping and have everything they need accessible to them. Additionally the middle area would make a beautiful community space.” - Respondent #185

“Concert series. Theater (broadway summer series was great at minthorne). Food trucks every weekend (multiple though). Lower cost events that allow people to come and go” - Respondent #187

“Playground, soccer field, fishing pier, things available to everyone. Free transit hub for access to snug harbor.” - Respondent #190

“We should have a Whole Foods there or lower the rent for storefront for local businesses” - Respondent #191

“more affordable stores and restaurants. more gyms” - Respondent #192

“I talk to tourists a lot. Many are surprised the mall is there so apparently no marketing is being done. They want food. I happily recommend neighborhood restaurants and many go but something between Wetzel's Pretzels and a sit down meal, like a Chipotle, should be available in the mall. But given the views there should also be more formal restaurants. There should be an area geared to commuters who need to do a few errands...bottle of wine, CVS, quick grocery shop so they can pick up dinner. How about pedi-bikes so tourists can easily access neighborhood amenities like the SI Museum, Snug Harbor, even as far as Ft. Wadsworth. How about free shuttle busses so tourists can go farther afield, for example, to the restaurants on Forest Ave? Tourists are actually curious about SI. Empire Outlets (i suggest taking the word Outlets out of the name) could be a springboard to the island. More creative use of open spaces such as a Dickens Xmas Village in 2nd level center court. High end pop-up stores for the holidays. Tiffany has done these in places like Grand Central.” - Respondent #195

“Boat rentals” - Respondent #196

“A park with trees and gardens with direct access to the waterfront. Small snack or food venues for the warmer months.” - Respondent #197

“The preservation of the feral cat colony in the “wheel site” security zone” - Respondent 199

“I would really love to see a public park space that values community over commercial endeavors. Open green space, waterfront access, and a center for community events and local art. Would love to see a music venue/gallery space that caters to locals. Somewhere to go dancing! Movies! (but would prefer an independent theater over a large chain.) Art museums! Sculpture park!” - Respondent #203

“Art and music venue. Movie theater. Community center w/ classes open to the public. Park space.” - Respondent #204

“Free Space for non profits and community programs providing services that enhance the quality of Staten Island. Many small organizations that are funded out of the pockets of community members could benefit from space to do the work that helps Staten Island thrive.” - Respondent #206

Primary stance ‍ ‍Responses ‍ ‍ Share

Support some form of housing: 112 56.9%

Oppose housing at the site: 64 32.5%

Conditional or limited housing: 17 8.6%

Unclear or nonresponsive: 4 2%

“Making the space high-end will fail. Attempting to compete with Manhattan in terms of retail offerings will fail. Make it useful for low to middle income people. Make rents accessible to small businesses.” - Respondent #9

“Either in the ferry terminal itself or the outlet there should be a Staten Island tourism office encouraging tourists to attend our local museums, parks, and restaurants. It should provide them with directions and information. This could be run by our Borough President's Office.” - Respondent #11

“It would be great if EDC consulted people who've researched what makes urban space vibrant and well-used. As far as I can tell, EDC works by 'rules of thumb' and on the advice of consultants who have no specific expertise of their own, and instead advise EDC to do what is done elsewhere. There are so so many social scientists who study related issues who could be empaneled to offer free advice at the cost of a catered lunch. They would have told EDC long ago that high end retailers  were not likely to open up outlets across the harbor from their Manhattan flagships and we'd be stuck with H&M and Gap and other stuff that can me found in every mall everywhere. (I know the EDC's narrative is that EO was defeated by the pandemic. That is a convenient explanation, but the concept was fundamentally flawed). They also could have helped you figure out how development on the waterfront could develop an economy by New York City's people, and for New York City’s people. I honestly do not know what model of economic development the EDC follows, how it projects how the benefits of its initiatives will be socially distributed. Dear god, please be more transparent.” - Respondent #14

“Look at the Brooklyn model; older neighborhoods with low height, housing close to shops. There’s a vibrant street life and a sense of community.  The current buildings are just big ugly space.” - Respondent #22

“Rather than one RFP for the whole site, EDC should have RFPs for different components of the property, so innovative, smaller ideas can be competitive.” -Respondent #25

“No more private equity groups that come in, draw out tax benefits, grants, etc an walk away.  This affects all of the residents of the area an we live with ghost buildings for years and decades” - Respondent #30

“DO NOT wish to see high rise expensive housing towers like Jersey City Waterfront” -Respondent #36

“We need continuous waterfront access from Jersey Street to the Alice Austen House” - Respondent #37

“Make this space more inviting it’s miserable at its current state lots of tourists come off ferry and are disappointed with what they see” - Respondent #44

“Please consider the area and what it stands for...hard working people who have experience everything that could be enjoyable on this end of the island either being taken away, insufficient for use or crowded with social service needs.  We are highly educated and have worked hard, many are home owners who have a vested interest in the North Shore hence having remained in spite of the lack of interest from the powers that be...don't turn this into downtown Brooklyn.” - Respondent #48

“We need to engage tourists coming from the ferry so they don’t just simply turn around and go back to Manhattan. The ferry terminal is uninviting and there is no signage or any indication that there is an entire mall tight outside. No information at all to draw the thousands of visitors to any businesses or cultural institutions throughout.” - Respondent #55

“The site of the wheel needs to have the bases removed and make it a green space on the water, the same way it was for years. Right now we have no access and it’s just a zombie construction site.” - Respondent #63

“With the addition of Brooklyn routes being added to NYC Ferry that serves Staten Island, the site may be funneling more Islanders traveling through for work or recreation in Manhattan & Brooklyn. It would benefit the site if those travelers could grab groceries or necessities on site.” - Respondent #65

“I am dubious of new commercial business seeing as how poorly EO has been utilized.  A proper grocery store, a bank, affordable housing, and water front access would go a long way to turning the space around.” - Respondent #68

“Having to pay for parking is a huge issue, I would visit outlets more if i could just go in spend and hour or two and leave. But having to pay for parking doesn’t make it worth it; I rather travel somewhere else were i don’t have to pay for parking.” - Respondent #69

“I am so tired of this area not getting its due. It is a fabulous location, fabulous views, it should be clean, safe, attractive to Staten Islanders to keep our younger generation on the Island. It should be a hip location, with upscale condos and coops, high end restaurants. Islanders should want to come here, it should be developed for STATEN ISLANDERS not for foreign tourists, as it was envisioned in the past, which was destined for failure.” - Respondent #74

“Yes. Anything there must be safe enough to allow families that live in SI to feel comfortable  frequenting the area.” - Respondent #77

“The Ferry Terminal hub by definition is a nexus of all points of our borough and must be designed in connection with the incremental plan for the entire borough's 50 year transportation plan, including crossborough and interborough wayfinding that overtime reduces dependency on privately owned cars, and enables most of our workers to earn their homeownership while working in the borough. This makes solving the St. George waterfront apiece and inseperably part of solving the North Shore Rail right of way, the Manhattan Brooklyn Staten Island Bayonne Public Rail Loop, and the blue highway of our fast ferry system.

The process cannot continue with endless public brainstorming and then private one-stroke deals with private equity investment firms that happen in a rash of election season last-minute announcements . We need public discourse incrementally outlining options for building PUBLICLY open waterfront in St George with growth experiences for every aspect of life food, fitness, education, employment, recreation, mobility and doing it with climate sustainability and land use resilience. Locally take care of our families needs from cradle to grave and the local economy part will grow organicly. Save the residential concerns for the upland and inland property so that the water perimeter is useable for the public.” - Respondent #81

“Please make sure it's accessible to broke ppl who like the water” - Respondent #83

“Look back at the original plans.  NOT THE WHEEL!.  There were wonderful ideas.  A food hall, famous stores and chefs to invest.  Entertainment opportunities for adults and children.  Hundreds of tourists are still coming off the ferry every day and walking around the empty outlets.  And there is an eager population in the community that would be use good businesses with a reputation.  Now we all travel to New Dorp and Bayonne” - Respondent #85

“I think this space needs a creative vision. I think the borough President should be actively working to investigate how other spaces in NYC in the other boroughs have successful spaces.” - Respondent #87

“The community got screwed with the development. There were amazing plans prior to the wheel that should be revisited. All the parts that would have served locals got trashed for corporate multinationals and a parking garage. What a disastrous waste of space and resources. Let’s do this right this time.” - Respondent #89

“The Outlets have been unsuccessful for a variety of reasons. I believe that part of the issue was poor marketing of the space. It seemed that it was not widely publicized in the appropriate places to let residents & tourists know of its existence. In addition, when you step off the ferry, there is not adequate signage to even let people know where to go to access the outlets. This is a site that should have been advertised in subways, tourists websites/guidebooks/hotels/TV/radio, etc. & there should also be lots of signs throughout the ferry terminals with directions & marketing for the outlets. The outlets also need a popular anchor store that attracts people like a Trader Joe's, Aldi, Lil, Whole Foods, etc.” - Respondent #94

“More reasonably priced entertainment options. The theatre there charges 35-40 a ticket.” - Respondent #96

“I would love a skateboard park and flag football fields” - Respondent #98

“When you look at what’s happened in places like DUMBO or Long Island City, it’s clear that with the right vision, a waterfront can become more than just a destination, it can become a daily part of people’s lives. Those neighborhoods found a way to mix in culture, creativity, and community in a way that keeps people coming back, not just for retail shopping. The location, the views, the foot traffic, it’s all there. What’s missing is a shift in how we think about it. If the focus moved toward activating the area with things that reflect the spirit of Staten Island, like local artists, food, music, and storytelling, it could actually become a place that feels alive, not just open.” - Respondent #104

“Staten Island is too overcrowded . The traffic is ridiculous and there isn’t much for our kids to do.  Not enough schools either. Tourists  get off the ferry and are disappointed that there is nothing to do or see.”- Respondent #106

“Stop putting in expensive bullshit. A low cost or free public space will attract more visitors than shopping while also doing more for the community. No one on SI goes to St. George willingly unless they absolutely have to.” -Respondent #107

“Many of us use the parking and the few shops that are there. It would be nice to still have access to those things while improving the use of the unused spaces.” - Respondent #110

“From what I see NYCEDC has mismanaged a lot of the projects in the area leading to eyesores and disappointment. I would hope that they would accept the opinions of the people who LIVE here and know its potential.” - Respondent #112

“As with many civic organizations, the median age of the membership is quite a bit higher than in the community overall. I hope that extra efforts will be made to gather feedback from our younger neighbors.” - Respondent #114

“This is public land and should be for use by public.” - Respondent #116

“I’m 73 years old and I’d like to see something great happen there before I pass on. So let’s go! Thanks for asking.” - Respondent #117

“Make this area comparable to the other beautiful and amazing waterfront areas in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens that is for exercise, culture and beauty and include Trader Joe’s.” - Respondent #121

“Let community decide” - Respondent #129

“Some part of the area designed to be so unique and interesting that tourists that missed the next ferry, would feel the desire to visit and spend money at the surrounding shops” - Respondent #132

“I’m very concerned about crime in the area. I don’t even take walks anymore and I fear walking to church.” - Respondent #134

“Bring back the north shore train, enough already the money is there. Connect the island=less buses=less traffic. The north shore deserves a train. Not just the south” - Respondent #136

“Is this for real? I've been on SI for 54 years and over the years, we've done umpteen visionary sessions.  It shouldn't be a commercial site. It should be like what they have in Brooklyn or Manhattan - a big cultural and green space for the public.” - Respondent #137

“BETTER PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION FOR ALL OF STATEN ISLAND.  MORE BUSES. MAYBE RE BUILDING THE NORTH SHORE RAPID TRANSIT TRAIN . FROM FERRY ALONG RICHMOND TERRACE TO SOUTH AVENUE.  WE NEED BETTER PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ON SI.” - Respondent #141

“No need for additional retail/commercial development. Also consider housing for the disabled.” - Respondent #150

“Honestly I don't feel that there was enough advertising for the empire outlets- there should've been a major push at the ferry to make it easy for folks to visit the outlets. I personally couldn't figure out how you navigate getting there and it seemed too far to walk. I never saw a sign for the outlets on the Manhattan side of the ferry. Also, If there was some sort of connection from the ferry to the outlets, like a shuttle or something (even just for the launch) it probably would have done better. Whatever gets put at that site needs a major push to encourage people to visit. It's a part of the island that really doesn't have anything to make people frequent it.” - Respondent #159

“Housing is going up all over St. George and very little new construction is actually occupied. The EO location was built for retail. It would best serve the community by bringing in businesses and organizations that would best serve the surrounding community.” - Respondent #160

“This area should be as beautiful and in demand living as Jersey city, LI city, DUMBO and other waterfront areas which have been thoughtfully and successfully rehabbed to thriving desirable neighborhoods. Our skyline views and free ferry access and now fast ferry access to Manhattan are unique and should be in demand.  This has been a political fail for decades and needs to be rectified. Then this overhaul needs to continue down the once beautiful and thriving areas of Tompkinsville and Stapleton. Start with making the area clean, safe and parking ensured so the locals and tourists will come and spent time and money in the area. The beautiful space of empire outlets needs to be revamped and rebranded to make an inviting space and hopefully more entertainment can be added to the Ferry hawks stadium which is a beautiful underutilized venue.” - Respondent #164

“It’s becoming a scary place for crime.  We need it to be populated with anything!” - Respondent #167

“I hate that parking garage built for the wheel. Can it be torn down? It ruined the views and feel of Richmond terrace.  I don’t want high rise buildings on the waterfront with low income housing or any housing.

I also don’t want it to become another public school or health clinic.

It needs to be something we can all benefit from. A place that feels safe and open to all families.

We need sports fields and more gourmet or specialty type food stores on the north shore. Brooklyn and manhattan have this, why can’t we.” - Respondent #169

“As a lifelong Staten Islander and longtime St. George resident, I have so much hope for our community. I look at waterfront neighborhoods like Williamsburg, DUMBO, and Long Island City and wonder why they’ve flourished while St. George has been left behind.

We’re still living with the consequences of broken promises: the abandoned NY Wheel site and the nearly empty, depressing Empire Outlets. These projects were driven by political and investor greed, not by consideration for the people who call this community home.

Now it’s on us to pick up the pieces and reimagine our waterfront; one that truly serves residents, inspires tourism, and creates much-needed housing for our growing population. Staten Island is a special place, and St. George is even more special. We deserve better.” - Respondent #170

“I don't know why St George seems cursed but it might be because we keep entrusting unvetted corporate bodies with projects instead of really having local resident and business input.  The whole wheel fiasco was avoidable if just one local government official checked the track record of the corporation proposing the project.” - Respondent #176

“The awful parking garage is a symbol for what happened to the site under commercial developers who ignored community wishes and input and NEEDS. Please don't do more of the same. Give us park space there for the public to use and enjoy, with green amenities.” - Respondent #180

“St. George has been ‘up and coming’ for as long as I can remember. I hope that insights from those of us who are actual residents are taken I to consideration.” - Respondent #183

“Im concerned with seeing all these apartments being built, but yet the community is still missing essentials like a supermarket, CVS, Walgreens” - Respondent #186

“Housing myst be supported with healthcare, affordable quality food, dry cleaner, drugstore, etc. Should not need to have a car.” - Respondent #188

“WE NEED A DOG PARK” - Respondent #189

“Don’t allow anyone who voted yes on the wheel project to have any say in what goes here on the future.” - Respondent #190

“I have worked at the Gap Factory since the mall opened. Borough Hall has supplied area maps maybe twice. The tourists take them but they are not resupplied. So...more local information, better signage in the mall, signs with neighborhood map showing restaurants, attractions.” - Respondent #195

“Please listen to the community this time.  We never wanted a Ferris wheel or an outlet mall.  Prior to these monstrosities, residents were able to walk right down to the actual waterfront and walk a lovely wooded path all the way to Jersey Street.  No more concrete structures.  Please give us something green like a park where people can relax, enjoy the view and get away from the hustle and bustle of the city.  There is nothing like looking out on the water to refresh one’s body and soul. Please give everyone an opportunity for such respite.  Why are Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens the only boroughs to get access to waterfront parks and recreation?” - Respondent #197

“Whatever happens, it should be public and open and the process needs to be transparent - no dodgy deals with real estate developers and shady contractors. Just like the Ferris wheel boondoggle.” - Respondent #199

“There needs to be feasability studies and market research for any project.  Any contractor must be investigated for corruption.” - Respondent #202

“More trees, less concrete!” - Respondent #203

“This space has amazing potential to change the lives of many Staten Islanders. I’m hoping that space for non- profits, housing, green spaces and health care/ wellness initiatives will find a new place to thrive. I would love to help plan what comes next” - Respondent #206